Sunday, November 15, 2026

Rigor -- what it isn't

Rigor is one of the most frequently invoked words in education, yet, I suggest, it is one of the least carefully examined. We use it to describe demanding courses and high academic expectations. We appeal to it when defending homework loads and assessment practices. Yet too often, what we mean by rigor is simply “lots of work.”

I want to challenge this understanding. A course with more reading is not necessarily more rigorous than one with less. An assignment that takes three hours is not inherently more valuable than one that takes 30 minutes. A difficult test does not, by virtue of its difficulty alone, measure deep understanding. And students who are exhausted by their academic responsibilities may simply be overworked rather than intellectually challenged.

Some schools have a peculiar tendency to celebrate difficulty as though it were an achievement in itself. We all know the teachers whose assignments have acquired almost mythical status, treated as crucibles through which students must pass to prove themselves. Somehow, the difficulty of surviving the course becomes a measure of the teacher's excellence. (This was my experience with a certain math teacher when I was in high school. Thus, I became an English teacher. But I digress.)

Ironically, making work difficult is easy. Making it intellectually demanding in ways that actually advance learning requires considerably more skill. Rigor resides not in the quantity of work assigned, but in the quality of thinking required. We must consider not only what students should know, but what we want them to be able to do with that knowledge. We need to distinguish between work that occupies students and work that changes their understanding. And we need the humility to acknowledge that an assignment we have always considered "rigorous" may be demanding for reasons that have little to do with learning.

A student who completes 20 mathematics problems using the same procedure may be practicing an important skill, but the 20th problem does not necessarily require more sophisticated thinking than the first. A student who can solve the 20th problem may not have needed all 19 that preceded it. And a student who cannot solve the first is unlikely to benefit from 19 more attempts without some additional instruction. What if, instead, we assigned five problems of increasing complexity? We could learn far more from where students begin to struggle than from whether they completed 20 repetitions.

We can apply the same principle to language learning. Rather than asking students to complete 20 sentences using the same grammatical structure, we might ask them to use that structure in increasingly complex contexts, moving from a familiar construction to one that requires them to make independent choices about language. Their responses would reveal not simply whether they had memorized a rule, but how well they understood it and where that understanding began to break down.

In both cases, the work becomes more useful because it tells us something about learning. We can see what students have mastered, where they need support, and whether they are ready for a greater challenge. The assignment serves a purpose beyond keeping students busy.

The whole idea for this article began when I was watching students play Wordle. I was struck by how absorbed they became in the game, how willingly they wrestled with the challenge, and how much satisfaction they took in figuring out the answer. We sometimes assume that students resist intellectual effort, but here was evidence to the contrary. Wordle gives players six attempts to solve a puzzle, with each guess providing information that helps them make the next one. The challenge is not to produce as many words as possible, but to use what they have learned from each attempt to make a better decision. There is real intellectual effort involved, and much joy in succeeding.

Genuine intellectual challenge requires students to move beyond what they already know how to do. It asks them to examine assumptions, recognize complexity, and reconsider conclusions. It requires sustained attention and sometimes considerable frustration. But the frustration has a purpose. Students are working toward understanding something they could not understand before. Our goal in designing lessons, therefore, should not be to manufacture struggle for its own sake, but to create the kind of intellectual challenge that makes struggle worthwhile.

It is one thing to identify challenging material and quite another to create the conditions in which students can engage with it meaningfully. Teachers must know when to offer guidance and when to step aside, when students need greater support and when they are capable of more than they realize. We should be cautious, then, about treating a reputation for difficulty as evidence of exceptional teaching. A classroom in which few students succeed may be exceptionally demanding. It may also be a classroom in which students have not been given the tools they need to succeed.

If we want rigorous classrooms, we need to look beyond the visible signs of academic demand. We need to examine the thinking students' work reveals and the understanding they carry forward. We need to ask whether our expectations are developing their capacity to reason independently or merely testing their ability to endure.

Students are capable of far more sophisticated thinking than we sometimes ask of them. We owe them challenges worthy of that capacity.

No comments:

Post a Comment

An Education in Its Own Right – When Preparation Becomes the Purpose

At some point, we seem to have decided that the purpose of high school is to get into college. We measure our success by the institutions to...