As an educator, I have always cared more about the process than the product. Perhaps that's why the International Baccalaureate program has always appealed to me. The IB places inquiry, reflection, and critical thinking at the center of learning. Students are expected to ask questions, explore ideas, reconsider assumptions, and develop their own understanding. Of course, there are final assessments, and those assessments matter. But the philosophy behind the program recognizes that learning is about much more than arriving at the right answer. That has always made sense to me. But not everyone agrees.
I've
worked in schools where the emphasis has been overwhelmingly on the product.
The grades, the test scores, the college acceptances, the impressive work that
can be displayed for parents or highlighted in a school publication or on the
school’s Instagram account. And while I understand why schools care about these
things, I've never been comfortable when they become the primary measure of
success. In fact, differences in educational philosophy have sometimes been
significant enough that I've chosen to leave.
I don't
think the purpose of education is to produce impressive work. I think it's to
develop people who are capable of doing impressive thinking. And now, with artificial intelligence, that
difference matters more than ever.
Much of
the conversation about AI in schools has centered on cheating. How do we know
whether a student wrote an essay? How do we prevent students from using AI to
complete assignments? How can we design assessments that AI can't do? These are
reasonable questions, but I think we're missing something. Why are we so
concerned about the finished product in the first place? When we ask students
to write an essay, solve a problem, or complete a research project, presumably
we aren't doing so because we need another essay, solution, or research
project. We're asking them to do these things because of what they will learn
in the process. The struggle to develop an argument, the frustration of
realizing that an approach isn't working, the discovery that comes from making
an unexpected connection. That's where the learning happens.
And that's
precisely what students can now bypass.
A student
can submit a beautifully written essay without having thought very much about
the subject at all. The essay might be excellent. It might even deserve an A if
we were grading only the quality of the writing. But what exactly would we be
assessing?
I've
always thought this was a problem with our approach to assessment, even before
AI entered the picture. We tell students that mistakes are opportunities for
learning, that revision matters, that intellectual risk-taking is important. We
encourage them to wrestle with difficult ideas and remind them that learning is
rarely a straight line. Then we grade what they hand in at the end.
Personally,
I'm interested in what happens to a student's thinking along the way. Can they
explain why they reached a particular conclusion? Can they recognize a weakness
in their argument? Can they consider another perspective without immediately
abandoning their own? Can they change their minds when presented with new
evidence? And perhaps most importantly, do they understand something at the end
that they didn't understand at the beginning? Those are the things I want us to
teach. And those are the things I want us to assess.
Of course,
this is easier said than done. It's much simpler to collect a final assignment
and evaluate it against a rubric than to assess the thinking that went into
producing it. And in schools, where time is always in short supply, simplicity
has its appeal. But AI has made it increasingly difficult to defend an approach
that relies so heavily on the finished product.
That
doesn't mean we should stop expecting students to produce good work. Quite the
opposite. I want students to write well, solve difficult problems, and
communicate their ideas effectively. I just don't want us to mistake the
quality of the product for evidence that learning has taken place.
Nor do I
think we should ban AI. There are ways to use it that can deepen thinking
rather than replace it. Asking AI to challenge an argument, for example, is
quite different from asking it to write the argument. Using it to explore
another perspective is different from accepting whatever perspective it
provides. The distinction is whether the student remains intellectually
engaged.
And that's
something we need to teach, too. And I think this is where schools have some
important decisions to make. We can't simply ask teachers to make their
assignments AI-proof and consider the problem solved. We need to have more
substantive conversations about what we value, what we expect students to
learn, and whether our assessment practices actually reflect those
priorities.
Schools
are under enormous pressure to demonstrate success. Parents want good grades.
Colleges want evidence of achievement. Boards want measurable outcomes. Schools
want to be able to point to results. I understand all of that. I've worked in
schools long enough to know that these pressures aren't going away. But we
should be able to distinguish between what is easy to measure and what is worth
measuring. AI hasn't changed my philosophy of education. If anything, it has
reinforced it.
For a long time, schools have been able to treat the product as a reasonable indication of the process that produced it. That was never a perfect assumption, but it was a convenient one. Now, AI has made it a much less reliable one. Maybe that's a good thing. Maybe it will finally force us to pay more attention to what students are actually learning rather than simply what they're producing. Because the product was never the point. The process was.
No comments:
Post a Comment